Peter Davis (Director) Rated: Suitable for 15 years and over Format: DVD Hearts And Minds [DVD] – A first-hand mosaic of the Vietnam war

Superb interval documentary and just as valid these days as it ever was. Our politicians nonetheless lie to us, and who pays the rate?.

It is interesting to observe a documentary that was possibly pretty disturbing at the time. Now, it’s in fact incredibly moderate. The biggest experience is that america’s leaders uncovered their lessons very well. No much more human body-bags, no a lot more draft, no more threats to the individuals at dwelling. We’ve been engaged in twenty yrs of war, and you can find been no successful groundswell of protest. It truly is just what transpires over there, and we get on with our lives. The corollary is that the most productive resource for getting into that war is in truth a threat to the people at dwelling.

Extremely joyful with merchandise and the provider.

I would just like way too say this need to be a single of the very best if not the dvds i have seen so much and would really advise this 1 also any body who has an fascination in this conflict.

This is the very best documentary i have ever witnessed, made just before the last humiliating pull-out in 1975. Terrific detail has been given in an before evaluation so i will not likely attempt the very same, but if you want to see the full horror of vietnam, not in a commentary but in terms of folks included,and the photographs of war and brutality, then buy this dvd. The lunacy of american policy gets to be plain in the words of the policy makers on their own, as is their just about whole ignorance of the vietnamese individuals and their insensitivity to human struggling. Sadly, you also realise that they appear to have realized very little from the war for the reason that in iraq and in foreign policy generally they present the exact attitudes and ignorance. Acquire it – you will never be unhappy.

Reviews from purchasers :

  • I feel somewhat shocked that I came across this by
  • Marvellous but harrowing account of the failings of the US campaign in Vietnam
  • 1974 Documentary Still Packs a Punch

Peter biskind’s very best-offering exploration of the new hollywood period ‘easy riders, raging bulls’ (later made into a so-so documentary of the same identify) presented up illustrations of the innovative angle injected into hollywood from the year zero in the late 1960s – arthur penn’s ‘bonnie & clyde. ‘ as biskind’s reserve demonstrates, for many years hollywood product become a great deal far more auteurist and radical with movie-makers such as hal ashby, peter bogdanovich, francis coppola, william friedkin & martin scorcese. Amid biskind’s exploration of american 70s cinema came sections on the output of ‘hearts & minds’ and later on, its controversial victory at the 1975 oscars. People who assume michael moore was the initially to scandalise with ‘bowling for columbine’ or are pointing in the direction of the latest crop of movies at 2006 oscars (‘syriana’,’brokeback mountain’ and so forth) as some type of radical indicator have obviously neglected this movie. & to be fair – this is quickly accomplished as it really is a documentary that have to be too painful for an american to check out – i doubt if george bush sr’s declare that the spectre of vietnam was buried in the arabian penisula circa the second gulf war of 1991 (following the to start with of 1980-1988). Director peter davis and producer bert schneider created one of these times when they outraged the old guard of hollywood (sinatra, fonda, hope et al) when accepting the award for ideal documentary they go through out a telegram from the provisional innovative governing administration of vietnam. Consider it that the united states had ostensibly lost the vietnam war, irrespective of whether in the part of backers of the french there (as ‘hearts & minds’ reveals 78% of funding for the french there just after wwii came from the usa- these cheese-eating surrender monkeys), in the most important war from the early sixties to the general us pullout in the early 70s, or to the south vietnamese drive backed by the us residents – famously usurped in 1975. This was unpleasant stuff – and ‘hearts & minds’ was definitely the to start with hollywood product to get to grip with what experienced just took place. ‘hearts & minds’ started out the approach that direct to this sort of films as ‘coming home’, ‘the deer hunter’, ‘tracks’, ‘apocalypse now’, the novel ‘first blood’, ‘dog soldiers’ (robert stone), ‘a brilliant shining lie’, ‘jack knife’, ‘platoon’, ‘full steel jacket’, ‘casualties of war’ etcetera. Davis’ film is shocking, as unlike the media managed wars considering that the pentagon did not embed/edit journalists and did not have compliant fox-tv type propaganda.

I found ‘hearts & minds’ to be a complete examination in why war is always a horrible and brutal occurence and why in every single solitary circumstance and no make any difference what nation is involved as a result of the many years it is the harmless that undergo (regardless of whether civilian or navy). The documentary begins by highlighting the peaceful village lifestyle of the ‘typical’ vietnamese villager and then progressively exposes the viewer to how innocence and daily life is destroyed as war evolves and consumes. Bottom line with ‘hearts & minds’ is that it does a commendable work in illustrating how the vietnam war was a final result of western government’s (usa’s) ‘false’ dread that communism would choose over the globe if not checked (the domino idea) together with some hidden political agendas that come to be apparent as the footage unfolds. The film also illustrates how the american / western individuals were being as harmless as the vietnamese in that in they didn’t actually realize the ‘reasons’ for the war?.The serving us troops are revealed in a a bit considerably less favourable light-weight (as is to be envisioned) nevertheless the film makers do a great job of demonstrating how the soldiers ended up ‘pawns’ of the us administration and as innocent as the us families and vietnamese villagers in the mix of it all. I could not see the position of donating five minutes of footage to two gi’s in a place with vietnamese girls that experienced turn out to be prostitutes or what point this scene was striving to express?. But ‘all in all’ it is the us federal government that ‘rightly’ will come out of the documentary as the main ‘villain’ eventhough the persons at the pretty top have been them selves completely ignorant of the vietnamese region, culture, persons and how all the vietnamese have wanted all over history is to be ‘free & independant’of all invaders whether or not western or communist. The $200m bucks per day of army help that north vietnam received from the ussr / china in the course of the conflict is not alluded to for whatsoever reason (possibly at the time of filming in 1974 this wasn’t regarded). In any case ‘hearts & minds’ is thoroughly well worth the order cost and my only ‘other’ suggestions would be look at it aspect by aspect with some other ‘rated’ documentaries on the issue matter to actually give an ‘all angles’ viewpoint.

I come to feel fairly shocked that i arrived across this by possibility on key. A actually effective documentary that does not hold back i would advise discretion as this vivid serious everyday living scenes of loss of life and injuries. Pretty poignant for it truly is time and illustrates the change of community viewpoint (on each sides of the fence) as the war progressed. Not generally that i look at a documentary and imagine ‘damn’.

Grew up with the viet nam war on the television set and radio, this is a condensed tale of it with some well-known graffic clips.

Excellant thought provoking and clever.

An extremely very good documentary. I like documentaries and rented this simply because it bought good testimonials and i did not know a enormous total about the vietnam war. There is no actual narrative and no commentary, but this documentary conveys the horrors of the vietnam war expertly. This movie employs war footage, interviews with soldiers, politicians, mother and father, victims, and is expertly edited in a way that the horror of the vietnam war, is felt with a tangible power. It’s exciting, and heartbreaking to look at in the context of latest functions. American presidents lied to their citizens, waged war on bogus pretexts, started out wars they failed to know how to end and served untold horrors on to innocent men and women thirty yrs in the past, and nonetheless existing administrations don’t seem to have learnt a hell of a lot. In point i wouldn’t be surprised if they recycled some of the speeches from back then – some of them audio depressingly familiarit’s a painful movie to check out but its a worthwhile physical exercise. I can not say i ‘enjoyed’ it, but i was in no way bored. It is too quick to fail to remember the human tragedy that accompanies the choices to go to war, and it is really the sort of movie that folks should really check out lest they forget about just how uncooked and destructive war is.

Doumentary about the get started of the vietnam war for american, and the soldiers and the idiots who sent them to war. Nevertheless a different war that the us made a decision to destroy a good deal of youthful gentlemen for.

The testimony of the individuals in this movie is a rather damning verdict on war and particularly us foreign plan in south east asia. We listen to from the politicians and advisers about the problems and calculating lies, there is footage of troopers on r and r [quite graphic and brutal and bloody sequences which serve to give you a good idea into the hell and mindset of the us soldiers. The americans unleashed total war on vietnam napalm, cluster bombs, and all kinds of chemicals that were sprayed to deforest the jungle and cause cancers- it is quite unbelievable to watch this documentary unfold and to realize that a similar war is going in albeit within a un code that still sees a superpower fighting an uncompromising opponent with weapons and homemade bombs. This is the warts and all reallity of war and you can’t look away even when you see something awful happens- perhaps if people saw this film it could change people’s ideas about the world. But then i’m a bit of a pessimist. ]

I ought to have watched this movie at the very least 10 occasions. It absolutely sure just isn’t for the ‘fun study,’ or ‘chick lit’ crowd. The 1st time was in the movie discussion board, in atlanta, in 1974, even though the american participation in the vietnam war was still on-likely. Like some other reviewers have reported, there was an absolute stunned silence when the film was around, with the moviegoers even hesitant to go away their seats. Soon after those people other viewings, is that peter davis really captured it all, perfectly, with a meticulous harmony. The vietnamese and the people in america, the ‘leaders,’ the fast-buck artists, the farmers, the foot soldiers, together with vignettes that shown the social and political forces that led the united states to vietnam, and resulted in it staying prolonged right after it was clear that it was a miscalculation. Actual, oh so true, that motion pictures that adopted, the deer hunter [dvd [1978], apocalypse now [blu-ray], heaven and earth [dvd] [1993] could never come close to. The difference: in all the others, after the movie was over, the actors washed away the “blood,” and stopped off on the way home for a couple of beers. In “hearts and minds,” the dead remain dead, and those without arms or legs remain that way. For those with personal experiences with the tragedy that was america’s participation in vietnam, like william marshall, a key interviewee, said: it just doesn’t all go away when you turn off the six o’clock news. Over the past 40 years, on one or two of the ten occasions i watched it alone. Other times, there was a “purpose. ” some canadian friends had a son who wanted to join their special forces, and sought me out in an effort to dissuade him. ]

The madness of american involvement in vietnam is laid bare. There is an irony continually alluded to all over this documentary that the us was born when it fought and defeated the mighty british empire – ‘these were being serious people’. The vietnamese were being similairly fighting for their independence, initially from chinese rule, then french and now american. Ho chi minh was supported clandestinely by the people for the duration of ww2. He lived for a though in the usa. He admired and highly regarded what they experienced completed in the war of independence and thought that the us would aid them overthrow the french colonial energy. The united states chose to side with the oppressors of the vietnamese and then took above from the french and invaded vietnam on a bogus pretext – the gulf of tonkin incident. Normal westmorland will come accross as a racist fool. The movie displays each individual american president was complicit in a criminal, murderous and shameful chapter in american background. The vietnamese won the war due to the fact they were fighting for their survival, the people lost since they had been combating for a lie.

Its not challenging to fathom the motives guiding the resurrection at the rear of this documentary. Three a long time soon after it gained finest documentary hearts and minds serves not just as an fantastic example of the documentary’s art but as a startling accurate, if inadvertent, prophecy of americas iraq misadventure. The toughness of davis’ delicate narrative- there is no voice above, and no presenter (a specified loud obese american could potentially study something from this procedure) – derives from his knowing what a shambles the vietnam war was. For this motive davies avoids mainly avoids anti-war voices, and as a substitute interviews all those who are for the war, banking that the foolishness of their sights will undermine their individual induce improved than any peacenik could. Especially noticeable is the late basic william westmoreland – most likely the biggest idiot ever to have worn stars on his shoulders. Most damning of all are davis’ interviews with veterans. Questioned if the united states has learnt anything at all from vietnam bomber pilot randy floyd replies: ‘i assume we’re hoping not to. ‘robert kennedy options in this documentary, and in a speech provided by him soon ahead of his assassination he confessed that he (and jfk) got it completely wrong a handful of a long time prior to under jfk administration on vietnam. At past any person experienced the guts to arrive clean about the sainted jfk’s blunder on vietnam. Unfortunately as robert kennedy was assassinated shortly soon after, we are going to hardly ever know if he would have turn into president and reversed the method his brother assisted start out.

A harrowing account of the lies different presidents propagated to their people today in their defence of the vietnamese marketing campaign, this oscar winning documentary (very well deserved) pulls no punches in portraying the horror and violence of the war both on the incumbent populace of north and south vietnam and also the us servicemen deployed out there in the 60s and 70s. It is quite significantly anti-war in it truly is sentiment, getting a reasoned assault on the presidents included from begin to end to suggest just how a lot of lies were created to the public to justify ‘american imperialistic ambitions’ in this much absent state. I find the xenophobic lifestyle of selected factions of the us inhabitants (the united states will save the environment from calamity yet again, that kind of detail) nauseating, still come to feel sad that we in the british isles really don’t have the satisfaction in our nation that ‘most’ but ‘not all’ of the american citizens have in theirs. That stated, vietnam turned a good deal of these people in america off the idealistic attitudes they held so expensive.

I have just viewed this documentary and it has impressed, appalled and educated me. It truly is expertly filmed and edited, the print and transfer are impeccable and it looks like it was made yesterday. The movie is a crystal clear and effective point of view on the real character of warfare and the real idiocy of us foreign policy through the vietnam war. It lets the members to explain to their own stories and typically provides them just enough rope to dangle on their own in the system. Some of the military and political comment has to be read to be considered. The persons of vietnam also notify their stories and seem much additional humane and informed than their aggressors (other than when combating for the latter). It is tough to perspective this superb film with no drawing parallels in between vietnam and iraq. Be aware: the documentary has some harrowing scenes of demise and mutilation but they are in context and extremely essential illustrations.

We shall not stop from exploration, and at the conclude of our exploringwill be to get there wherever we startedand to know this spot for the initial time. Why do we continue to make human errors?. What is incorrect with human beings beings?.This 1975 documentary gained best’ documentary’ and all these years afterwards it reflects an precise, if inadvertent, prophecy of americas iraq misadventure. With out authorization from nato, and that is why it is an unlawful invasion. Thhis fantastic docu is odd- there is no voice above, and no presenter (a specified loud obese american with an oirish name could quite possibly understand something from this strategy) and this docu maps out how what a shambles the vietnam war was. For this motive davies (director/creator) avoids largely avoids anti-war voices, and as a substitute interviews these who are for the war, banking that the foolishness of their views will undermine their individual bring about far better than any peace entire persons could.

This is an exceptional documentary and i did not discover it unduly harrowing, as is perhaps instructed by other reviewers. There is no narrative, rather news clips and interviews are pieced alongside one another to permit the articles to speak for alone. Interviewees include soldiers and civilians from all sides, like walt rostow and william westmoreland. The latter seems in the movie to be startlingly unsophisticated and his sights on the `asian absence of appreciation for the price human life’ are chillingly juxtaposed with footage of grieving families of south vietnamese armed forces casualties. I’ve study a good deal about vietnam, but nothing at all that i have study has been as helpful as viewing `hearts and minds’ in giving me with an appreciation of the human dimension to the conflict.

This is one motion picture what attempt to make some feeling from the time of american musolinism greater than excellent shining propaganda lie.

Summary
Review Date
Reviewed Item
Hearts And Minds [DVD]
Rating
5.0 of 5 stars, based on 33 reviews

1 comment on “Peter Davis (Director) Rated: Suitable for 15 years and over Format: DVD Hearts And Minds [DVD] – A first-hand mosaic of the Vietnam war

  1. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    It’s interesting to watch a documentary that was probably very disturbing at the time. Now, it’s actually very mild. The biggest feeling is that america’s leaders learned their lessons well. No more body-bags, no more draft, no more threats to the folks at home. We’ve been engaged in twenty years of war, and there’s been no effective groundswell of protest. It’s just what happens over there, and we get on with our lives. The corollary is that the most effective tool for getting into that war is indeed a threat to the folks at home.
    1. It’s interesting to watch a documentary that was probably very disturbing at the time. Now, it’s actually very mild. The biggest feeling is that america’s leaders learned their lessons well. No more body-bags, no more draft, no more threats to the folks at home. We’ve been engaged in twenty years of war, and there’s been no effective groundswell of protest. It’s just what happens over there, and we get on with our lives. The corollary is that the most effective tool for getting into that war is indeed a threat to the folks at home.
  2. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    I would just like too say this must be one of the best if not the dvds i’ve seen so far and would highly recommend this one too any body who has an interest in this conflict.
  3. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    I would just like too say this must be one of the best if not the dvds i’ve seen so far and would highly recommend this one too any body who has an interest in this conflict.
    1. I feel somewhat shocked that i came across this by chance on prime. A really powerful documentary that does not hold back; i’d advise discretion as this vivid real life scenes of death and injury. Very poignant for it’s time and illustrates the shift of public opinion (on both sides of the fence) as the war progressed. Not often that i watch a documentary and think ‘damn’.
  4. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    I feel somewhat shocked that i came across this by chance on prime. A really powerful documentary that does not hold back; i’d advise discretion as this vivid real life scenes of death and injury. Very poignant for it’s time and illustrates the shift of public opinion (on both sides of the fence) as the war progressed. Not often that i watch a documentary and think ‘damn’.
    1. Excellent period documentary and just as valid today as it ever was. Our politicians still lie to us, and who pays the price?.
      1. Excellent period documentary and just as valid today as it ever was. Our politicians still lie to us, and who pays the price?.
  5. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    This is one movie what attempt to make some sense from the time of american musolinism better than great shining propaganda lie.
  6. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    This is one movie what attempt to make some sense from the time of american musolinism better than great shining propaganda lie.
    1. I must have watched this movie at least ten times. It sure isn’t for the “fun read,” or “chick lit” crowd. The first time was in the film forum, in atlanta, in 1974, while the american participation in the vietnam war was still on-going. Like some other reviewers have reported, there was an absolute stunned silence when the movie was over, with the moviegoers even reluctant to leave their seats. After those other viewings, is that peter davis truly captured it all, perfectly, with a meticulous balance. The vietnamese and the americans, the “leaders,” the quick-buck artists, the farmers, the foot soldiers, along with vignettes that demonstrated the social and political forces that led america to vietnam, and resulted in it staying long after it was apparent that it was a mistake. Real, oh so real, that movies that followed, the deer hunter [dvd] [1978], apocalypse now [blu-ray], heaven and earth [dvd] [1993] could never come close to. The difference: in all the others, after the movie was over, the actors washed away the “blood,” and stopped off on the way home for a couple of beers. In “hearts and minds,” the dead remain dead, and those without arms or legs remain that way. For those with personal experiences with the tragedy that was america’s participation in vietnam, like william marshall, a key interviewee, said: it just doesn’t all go away when you turn off the six o’clock news. Over the past 40 years, on one or two of the ten occasions i watched it alone. Other times, there was a “purpose. ” some canadian friends had a son who wanted to join their special forces, and sought me out in an effort to dissuade him.
      1. I must have watched this movie at least ten times. It sure isn’t for the “fun read,” or “chick lit” crowd. The first time was in the film forum, in atlanta, in 1974, while the american participation in the vietnam war was still on-going. Like some other reviewers have reported, there was an absolute stunned silence when the movie was over, with the moviegoers even reluctant to leave their seats. After those other viewings, is that peter davis truly captured it all, perfectly, with a meticulous balance. The vietnamese and the americans, the “leaders,” the quick-buck artists, the farmers, the foot soldiers, along with vignettes that demonstrated the social and political forces that led america to vietnam, and resulted in it staying long after it was apparent that it was a mistake. Real, oh so real, that movies that followed, the deer hunter [dvd] [1978], apocalypse now [blu-ray], heaven and earth [dvd] [1993] could never come close to. The difference: in all the others, after the movie was over, the actors washed away the “blood,” and stopped off on the way home for a couple of beers. In “hearts and minds,” the dead remain dead, and those without arms or legs remain that way. For those with personal experiences with the tragedy that was america’s participation in vietnam, like william marshall, a key interviewee, said: it just doesn’t all go away when you turn off the six o’clock news. Over the past 40 years, on one or two of the ten occasions i watched it alone. Other times, there was a “purpose. ” some canadian friends had a son who wanted to join their special forces, and sought me out in an effort to dissuade him.
  7. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    Grew up with the viet nam war on the tv and radio, this is a condensed story of it with some famous graffic clips.
  8. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    Grew up with the viet nam war on the tv and radio, this is a condensed story of it with some famous graffic clips.
  9. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    A harrowing account of the lies various presidents propagated to their people in their defence of the vietnamese campaign, this oscar winning documentary (well deserved) pulls no punches in portraying the horror and violence of the war both on the incumbent population of north and south vietnam and also the us servicemen deployed out there in the 60s and 70s. It is pretty much anti-war in it’s sentiment, having a reasoned attack on the presidents involved from start to finish to indicate just how many lies were made to the public to justify “american imperialistic ambitions” in this far away country. I find the xenophobic culture of certain factions of the us population (america saves the world from calamity yet again, that sort of thing) nauseating, yet feel sad that we in the uk don’t have the pride in our nation that “most” but “not all” of the american citizens have in theirs. That said, vietnam turned a lot of these americans off the idealistic attitudes they held so dear.
  10. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    A harrowing account of the lies various presidents propagated to their people in their defence of the vietnamese campaign, this oscar winning documentary (well deserved) pulls no punches in portraying the horror and violence of the war both on the incumbent population of north and south vietnam and also the us servicemen deployed out there in the 60s and 70s. It is pretty much anti-war in it’s sentiment, having a reasoned attack on the presidents involved from start to finish to indicate just how many lies were made to the public to justify “american imperialistic ambitions” in this far away country. I find the xenophobic culture of certain factions of the us population (america saves the world from calamity yet again, that sort of thing) nauseating, yet feel sad that we in the uk don’t have the pride in our nation that “most” but “not all” of the american citizens have in theirs. That said, vietnam turned a lot of these americans off the idealistic attitudes they held so dear.
  11. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    Doumentary about the start of the vietnam war for american, and the soldiers and the idiots who sent them to war. Yet another war that america decided to kill a lot of young men for.
  12. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    Doumentary about the start of the vietnam war for american, and the soldiers and the idiots who sent them to war. Yet another war that america decided to kill a lot of young men for.
  13. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    The insanity of american involvement in vietnam is laid bare. There is an irony consistently alluded to throughout this documentary that the us was born when it fought and defeated the mighty british empire – ‘these were real people’. The vietnamese were similairly fighting for their independence, first from chinese rule, then french and now american. Ho chi minh was supported clandestinely by the americans during ww2. He lived for a while in america. He admired and respected what they had done in the war of independence and believed that america would help them overthrow the french colonial power. America chose to side with the oppressors of the vietnamese and then took over from the french and invaded vietnam on a false pretext – the gulf of tonkin incident. General westmorland comes accross as a racist fool. The film shows each american president was complicit in a criminal, murderous and shameful chapter in american history. The vietnamese won the war because they were fighting for their survival, the americans lost because they were fighting for a lie.
  14. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    The insanity of american involvement in vietnam is laid bare. There is an irony consistently alluded to throughout this documentary that the us was born when it fought and defeated the mighty british empire – ‘these were real people’. The vietnamese were similairly fighting for their independence, first from chinese rule, then french and now american. Ho chi minh was supported clandestinely by the americans during ww2. He lived for a while in america. He admired and respected what they had done in the war of independence and believed that america would help them overthrow the french colonial power. America chose to side with the oppressors of the vietnamese and then took over from the french and invaded vietnam on a false pretext – the gulf of tonkin incident. General westmorland comes accross as a racist fool. The film shows each american president was complicit in a criminal, murderous and shameful chapter in american history. The vietnamese won the war because they were fighting for their survival, the americans lost because they were fighting for a lie.
    1. I found ‘hearts & minds’ to be a thorough examination in why war is always a terrible and brutal occurence and why in every single case and no matter what country is involved through the decades it is the innocent that suffer (whether civilian or military). The documentary begins by highlighting the quiet village life of the ‘typical’ vietnamese villager and then progressively exposes the viewer to how innocence and life is destroyed as war evolves and consumes. Bottom line with ‘hearts & minds’ is that it does a commendable job in illustrating how the vietnam war was a result of western government’s (usa’s) ‘false’ fear that communism would take over the world if not checked (the domino theory) along with some hidden political agendas that become apparent as the footage unfolds. The film also illustrates how the american / western people were as innocent as the vietnamese in that in they didn’t really understand the ‘reasons’ for the war?.The serving us troops are shown in a slightly less favourable light (as is to be expected) however the film makers do a good job of demonstrating how the soldiers were ‘pawns’ of the us administration and as innocent as the us families and vietnamese villagers in the mix of it all. I couldn’t see the point of donating 5 minutes of footage to two gi’s in a room with vietnamese girls that had become prostitutes or what point this scene was trying to convey?. But ‘all in all’ it is the us government that ‘rightly’ comes out of the documentary as the chief ‘villain’ eventhough the individuals at the very top were themselves totally ignorant of the vietnamese country, culture, people and how all the vietnamese have wanted throughout history is to be ‘free & independant’of all invaders whether western or communist. The $200m dollars per day of military aid that north vietnam received from the ussr / china during the conflict isn’t alluded to for whatever reason (maybe at the time of filming in 1974 this wasn’t known). Anyway ‘hearts & minds’ is totally worth the purchase price and my only ‘other’ advice would be view it side by side with some other ‘rated’ documentaries on the subject matter to really give an ‘all angles’ viewpoint.
  15. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    I found ‘hearts & minds’ to be a thorough examination in why war is always a terrible and brutal occurence and why in every single case and no matter what country is involved through the decades it is the innocent that suffer (whether civilian or military). The documentary begins by highlighting the quiet village life of the ‘typical’ vietnamese villager and then progressively exposes the viewer to how innocence and life is destroyed as war evolves and consumes. Bottom line with ‘hearts & minds’ is that it does a commendable job in illustrating how the vietnam war was a result of western government’s (usa’s) ‘false’ fear that communism would take over the world if not checked (the domino theory) along with some hidden political agendas that become apparent as the footage unfolds. The film also illustrates how the american / western people were as innocent as the vietnamese in that in they didn’t really understand the ‘reasons’ for the war?.The serving us troops are shown in a slightly less favourable light (as is to be expected) however the film makers do a good job of demonstrating how the soldiers were ‘pawns’ of the us administration and as innocent as the us families and vietnamese villagers in the mix of it all. I couldn’t see the point of donating 5 minutes of footage to two gi’s in a room with vietnamese girls that had become prostitutes or what point this scene was trying to convey?. But ‘all in all’ it is the us government that ‘rightly’ comes out of the documentary as the chief ‘villain’ eventhough the individuals at the very top were themselves totally ignorant of the vietnamese country, culture, people and how all the vietnamese have wanted throughout history is to be ‘free & independant’of all invaders whether western or communist. The $200m dollars per day of military aid that north vietnam received from the ussr / china during the conflict isn’t alluded to for whatever reason (maybe at the time of filming in 1974 this wasn’t known). Anyway ‘hearts & minds’ is totally worth the purchase price and my only ‘other’ advice would be view it side by side with some other ‘rated’ documentaries on the subject matter to really give an ‘all angles’ viewpoint.
  16. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    The testimony of the people in this film is a pretty damning verdict on war and especially us foreign policy in south east asia. We hear from the politicians and advisers about the mistakes and calculating lies, there is footage of soldiers on r and r [pretty graphic] and brutal and bloody sequences which serve to give you a good idea into the hell and mindset of the us soldiers. The americans unleashed total war on vietnam napalm, cluster bombs, and all kinds of chemicals that were sprayed to deforest the jungle and cause cancers- it is quite unbelievable to watch this documentary unfold and to realize that a similar war is going in albeit within a un code that still sees a superpower fighting an uncompromising opponent with weapons and homemade bombs. This is the warts and all reallity of war and you can’t look away even when you see something awful happens- perhaps if people saw this film it could change people’s ideas about the world. But then i’m a bit of a pessimist.
    1. The testimony of the people in this film is a pretty damning verdict on war and especially us foreign policy in south east asia. We hear from the politicians and advisers about the mistakes and calculating lies, there is footage of soldiers on r and r [pretty graphic] and brutal and bloody sequences which serve to give you a good idea into the hell and mindset of the us soldiers. The americans unleashed total war on vietnam napalm, cluster bombs, and all kinds of chemicals that were sprayed to deforest the jungle and cause cancers- it is quite unbelievable to watch this documentary unfold and to realize that a similar war is going in albeit within a un code that still sees a superpower fighting an uncompromising opponent with weapons and homemade bombs. This is the warts and all reallity of war and you can’t look away even when you see something awful happens- perhaps if people saw this film it could change people’s ideas about the world. But then i’m a bit of a pessimist.
  17. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    The american government does terrible things in the name of its people, but one of its redeeming qualities as a nation is the ability of its media to expose its powerful men, and give a voice to articulate men who have seen the error of their ways. This film provides the historical background to the vietnam war. General westmoreland and other statesmen reveal their own arrogance and lack of understanding. The director reveals the terrible lies that people tell in power and the stupidity of the “jupiter complex” – dropping bombs on helpless civilians. Americans talk about the genocide and chemical weapons used by saddam hussein – well what about their campaign in vietnam?. This is wonderful film-making. Intelligent, heart-rending, sad and true.
  18. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    The american government does terrible things in the name of its people, but one of its redeeming qualities as a nation is the ability of its media to expose its powerful men, and give a voice to articulate men who have seen the error of their ways. This film provides the historical background to the vietnam war. General westmoreland and other statesmen reveal their own arrogance and lack of understanding. The director reveals the terrible lies that people tell in power and the stupidity of the “jupiter complex” – dropping bombs on helpless civilians. Americans talk about the genocide and chemical weapons used by saddam hussein – well what about their campaign in vietnam?. This is wonderful film-making. Intelligent, heart-rending, sad and true.
    1. The vietnam war was the most photographed and broadcast war in history. Nightly news arrived in our living rooms pretty much unfiltered documenting the shocking story day by day. Peter davis set out to make a documentary about the conflict which sought to present the war without some sanitising voiceover filtering the impact. “hearts & minds” is the result. The film simply documents both the shocking and the banal and despite there being nothing to link this film by ways of a voiceover it has an impressive narrative power. The images are very powerful. The infamous shot of the girl running naked from a napalm attack and the vietcong man shot in the head are both shocking and iconographic still photos here shown as live and in motion, doubly shocking for being in vivid colour. This film has an extraordinary power. What shocks most are the desperate justifications by government officials and the blinding racist ignorance of some of the fighting people. Many see the people of vietnam as less than human which must have shocked then and still does now.
      1. The vietnam war was the most photographed and broadcast war in history. Nightly news arrived in our living rooms pretty much unfiltered documenting the shocking story day by day. Peter davis set out to make a documentary about the conflict which sought to present the war without some sanitising voiceover filtering the impact. “hearts & minds” is the result. The film simply documents both the shocking and the banal and despite there being nothing to link this film by ways of a voiceover it has an impressive narrative power. The images are very powerful. The infamous shot of the girl running naked from a napalm attack and the vietcong man shot in the head are both shocking and iconographic still photos here shown as live and in motion, doubly shocking for being in vivid colour. This film has an extraordinary power. What shocks most are the desperate justifications by government officials and the blinding racist ignorance of some of the fighting people. Many see the people of vietnam as less than human which must have shocked then and still does now.
  19. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    We shall not cease from exploration, and at the end of our exploringwill be to arrive where we startedand to know this place for the first time. Why do we continue to make human mistakes?. What is wrong with humans beings?.This 1975 documentary won best’ documentary’ and all these years later it reflects an accurate, if inadvertent, prophecy of americas iraq misadventure. Without permission from nato, and that is why it is an illegal invasion. Thhis brilliant docu is strange- there is no voice over, and no presenter (a certain loud overweight american with an oirish name could possibly learn something from this technique) and this docu maps out how what a shambles the vietnam war was. For this reason davies (director/creator) avoids largely avoids anti-war voices, and instead interviews those who are for the war, banking that the foolishness of their views will undermine their own cause better than any peace full people could.
    1. We shall not cease from exploration, and at the end of our exploringwill be to arrive where we startedand to know this place for the first time. Why do we continue to make human mistakes?. What is wrong with humans beings?.This 1975 documentary won best’ documentary’ and all these years later it reflects an accurate, if inadvertent, prophecy of americas iraq misadventure. Without permission from nato, and that is why it is an illegal invasion. Thhis brilliant docu is strange- there is no voice over, and no presenter (a certain loud overweight american with an oirish name could possibly learn something from this technique) and this docu maps out how what a shambles the vietnam war was. For this reason davies (director/creator) avoids largely avoids anti-war voices, and instead interviews those who are for the war, banking that the foolishness of their views will undermine their own cause better than any peace full people could.
  20. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    Its not difficult to fathom the motives behind the resurrection behind this documentary. Three decades after it won best documentary hearts and minds serves not just as an outstanding example of the documentary’s art but as a startling accurate, if inadvertent, prophecy of americas iraq misadventure. The strength of davis’ subtle narrative- there is no voice over, and no presenter (a certain loud overweight american could possibly learn something from this technique) – derives from his understanding what a shambles the vietnam war was. For this reason davies avoids largely avoids anti-war voices, and instead interviews those who are for the war, banking that the foolishness of their views will undermine their own cause better than any peacenik could. Particularly visible is the late general william westmoreland – probably the biggest idiot ever to have worn stars on his shoulders. Most damning of all are davis’ interviews with veterans. Asked if america has learnt anything from vietnam bomber pilot randy floyd replies: “i think we’re trying not to. “robert kennedy features in this documentary, and in a speech given by him shortly before his assassination he confessed that he (and jfk) got it wrong a few years before under jfk administration on vietnam. At last somebody had the guts to come clean about the sainted jfk’s mistake on vietnam. Sadly as robert kennedy was assassinated shortly after, we’ll never know if he would have become president and reversed the process his brother helped start.
  21. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    Its not difficult to fathom the motives behind the resurrection behind this documentary. Three decades after it won best documentary hearts and minds serves not just as an outstanding example of the documentary’s art but as a startling accurate, if inadvertent, prophecy of americas iraq misadventure. The strength of davis’ subtle narrative- there is no voice over, and no presenter (a certain loud overweight american could possibly learn something from this technique) – derives from his understanding what a shambles the vietnam war was. For this reason davies avoids largely avoids anti-war voices, and instead interviews those who are for the war, banking that the foolishness of their views will undermine their own cause better than any peacenik could. Particularly visible is the late general william westmoreland – probably the biggest idiot ever to have worn stars on his shoulders. Most damning of all are davis’ interviews with veterans. Asked if america has learnt anything from vietnam bomber pilot randy floyd replies: “i think we’re trying not to. “robert kennedy features in this documentary, and in a speech given by him shortly before his assassination he confessed that he (and jfk) got it wrong a few years before under jfk administration on vietnam. At last somebody had the guts to come clean about the sainted jfk’s mistake on vietnam. Sadly as robert kennedy was assassinated shortly after, we’ll never know if he would have become president and reversed the process his brother helped start.
    1. This is an excellent documentary and i did not find it unduly harrowing, as is perhaps suggested by other reviewers. There is no narrative, instead news clips and interviews are pieced together to allow the content to speak for itself. Interviewees include soldiers and civilians from all sides, including walt rostow and william westmoreland. The latter appears in the film to be startlingly unsophisticated and his views on the `asian lack of appreciation for the value human life’ are chillingly juxtaposed with footage of grieving families of south vietnamese military casualties. I’ve read a lot about vietnam, but nothing that i have read has been as effective as watching `hearts and minds’ in providing me with an appreciation of the human dimension to the conflict.
  22. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    This is an excellent documentary and i did not find it unduly harrowing, as is perhaps suggested by other reviewers. There is no narrative, instead news clips and interviews are pieced together to allow the content to speak for itself. Interviewees include soldiers and civilians from all sides, including walt rostow and william westmoreland. The latter appears in the film to be startlingly unsophisticated and his views on the `asian lack of appreciation for the value human life’ are chillingly juxtaposed with footage of grieving families of south vietnamese military casualties. I’ve read a lot about vietnam, but nothing that i have read has been as effective as watching `hearts and minds’ in providing me with an appreciation of the human dimension to the conflict.
    1. An exceptionally good documentary. I love documentaries and rented this because it got good reviews and i didn’t know a huge amount about the vietnam war. There is no real narrative and no commentary, but this documentary conveys the horrors of the vietnam war expertly. This film uses war footage, interviews with soldiers, politicians, parents, victims, and is expertly edited in a way that the horror of the vietnam war, is felt with a tangible force. It’s interesting, and heartbreaking to watch in the context of current events. American presidents lied to their citizens, waged war on false pretexts, started wars they didn’t know how to finish and served untold horrors onto innocent people 30 years ago, and yet current administrations don’t seem to have learnt a hell of a lot. In fact i wouldn’t be surprised if they recycled some of the speeches from back then – some of them sound depressingly familiarit’s a painful film to watch but its a worthwhile exercise. I can’t say i ‘enjoyed’ it, but i was never bored. It’s too easy to forget the human tragedy that accompanies the decisions to go to war, and it’s the kind of film that people should watch lest they forget just how raw and destructive war is.
      1. An exceptionally good documentary. I love documentaries and rented this because it got good reviews and i didn’t know a huge amount about the vietnam war. There is no real narrative and no commentary, but this documentary conveys the horrors of the vietnam war expertly. This film uses war footage, interviews with soldiers, politicians, parents, victims, and is expertly edited in a way that the horror of the vietnam war, is felt with a tangible force. It’s interesting, and heartbreaking to watch in the context of current events. American presidents lied to their citizens, waged war on false pretexts, started wars they didn’t know how to finish and served untold horrors onto innocent people 30 years ago, and yet current administrations don’t seem to have learnt a hell of a lot. In fact i wouldn’t be surprised if they recycled some of the speeches from back then – some of them sound depressingly familiarit’s a painful film to watch but its a worthwhile exercise. I can’t say i ‘enjoyed’ it, but i was never bored. It’s too easy to forget the human tragedy that accompanies the decisions to go to war, and it’s the kind of film that people should watch lest they forget just how raw and destructive war is.
  23. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    This is the best documentary i have ever seen, made before the final humiliating pull-out in 1975. Great detail has been given in an earlier review so i won’t attempt the same, but if you want to see the full horror of vietnam, not in a commentary but in words of people involved,and the images of war and brutality, then buy this dvd. The lunacy of american policy becomes plain in the words of the policy makers themselves, as is their almost total ignorance of the vietnamese people and their insensitivity to human suffering. Sadly, you also realise that they seem to have learned nothing from the war because in iraq and in foreign policy generally they show the same attitudes and ignorance. Buy it – you won’t be disappointed.
  24. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    This is the best documentary i have ever seen, made before the final humiliating pull-out in 1975. Great detail has been given in an earlier review so i won’t attempt the same, but if you want to see the full horror of vietnam, not in a commentary but in words of people involved,and the images of war and brutality, then buy this dvd. The lunacy of american policy becomes plain in the words of the policy makers themselves, as is their almost total ignorance of the vietnamese people and their insensitivity to human suffering. Sadly, you also realise that they seem to have learned nothing from the war because in iraq and in foreign policy generally they show the same attitudes and ignorance. Buy it – you won’t be disappointed.
  25. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    Peter biskind’s best-selling exploration of the new hollywood era ‘easy riders, raging bulls’ (later made into a so-so documentary of the same name) offered up examples of the revolutionary attitude injected into hollywood from the year zero in the late 1960s – arthur penn’s ‘bonnie & clyde. ‘ as biskind’s book demonstrates, for several years hollywood product become much more auteurist and radical with film-makers such as hal ashby, peter bogdanovich, francis coppola, william friedkin & martin scorcese. Amid biskind’s exploration of american 70s cinema came sections on the production of ‘hearts & minds’ and later, its controversial victory at the 1975 oscars. People who think michael moore was the first to scandalise with ‘bowling for columbine’ or are pointing towards the recent crop of films at 2006 oscars (‘syriana’,’brokeback mountain’ etc) as some sort of radical indicator have clearly forgotten this film. & to be fair – this is easily done as it’s a documentary that must be too painful for an american to watch – i doubt if george bush sr’s claim that the spectre of vietnam was buried in the arabian penisula circa the second gulf war of 1991 (after the first of 1980-1988). Director peter davis and producer bert schneider created one of those moments when they outraged the old guard of hollywood (sinatra, fonda, hope et al) when accepting the award for best documentary they read out a telegram from the provisional revolutionary government of vietnam. Take it that america had ostensibly lost the vietnam war, whether in the role of backers of the french there (as ‘hearts & minds’ reveals 78% of funding for the french there after wwii came from america- those cheese-eating surrender monkeys), in the main war from the early 1960s to the general us pullout in the early 70s, or to the south vietnamese force backed by the americans – famously usurped in 1975. This was painful stuff – and ‘hearts & minds’ was really the first hollywood product to get to grip with what had just happened. ‘hearts & minds’ started the process that lead towards such films as ‘coming home’, ‘the deer hunter’, ‘tracks’, ‘apocalypse now’, the novel ‘first blood’, ‘dog soldiers’ (robert stone), ‘a bright shining lie’, ‘jack knife’, ‘platoon’, ‘full metal jacket’, ‘casualties of war’ etc. Davis’ film is shocking, as unlike the media managed wars since the pentagon did not embed/edit journalists and did not have compliant fox-tv style propaganda.
  26. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    Peter biskind’s best-selling exploration of the new hollywood era ‘easy riders, raging bulls’ (later made into a so-so documentary of the same name) offered up examples of the revolutionary attitude injected into hollywood from the year zero in the late 1960s – arthur penn’s ‘bonnie & clyde. ‘ as biskind’s book demonstrates, for several years hollywood product become much more auteurist and radical with film-makers such as hal ashby, peter bogdanovich, francis coppola, william friedkin & martin scorcese. Amid biskind’s exploration of american 70s cinema came sections on the production of ‘hearts & minds’ and later, its controversial victory at the 1975 oscars. People who think michael moore was the first to scandalise with ‘bowling for columbine’ or are pointing towards the recent crop of films at 2006 oscars (‘syriana’,’brokeback mountain’ etc) as some sort of radical indicator have clearly forgotten this film. & to be fair – this is easily done as it’s a documentary that must be too painful for an american to watch – i doubt if george bush sr’s claim that the spectre of vietnam was buried in the arabian penisula circa the second gulf war of 1991 (after the first of 1980-1988). Director peter davis and producer bert schneider created one of those moments when they outraged the old guard of hollywood (sinatra, fonda, hope et al) when accepting the award for best documentary they read out a telegram from the provisional revolutionary government of vietnam. Take it that america had ostensibly lost the vietnam war, whether in the role of backers of the french there (as ‘hearts & minds’ reveals 78% of funding for the french there after wwii came from america- those cheese-eating surrender monkeys), in the main war from the early 1960s to the general us pullout in the early 70s, or to the south vietnamese force backed by the americans – famously usurped in 1975. This was painful stuff – and ‘hearts & minds’ was really the first hollywood product to get to grip with what had just happened. ‘hearts & minds’ started the process that lead towards such films as ‘coming home’, ‘the deer hunter’, ‘tracks’, ‘apocalypse now’, the novel ‘first blood’, ‘dog soldiers’ (robert stone), ‘a bright shining lie’, ‘jack knife’, ‘platoon’, ‘full metal jacket’, ‘casualties of war’ etc. Davis’ film is shocking, as unlike the media managed wars since the pentagon did not embed/edit journalists and did not have compliant fox-tv style propaganda.
  27. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    I’ve just watched this documentary and it has impressed, appalled and educated me. It’s expertly filmed and edited, the print and transfer are impeccable and it looks like it was made yesterday. The film is a clear and powerful perspective on the true nature of warfare and the true idiocy of us foreign policy during the vietnam war. It allows the participants to tell their own stories and often gives them just enough rope to hang themselves in the process. Some of the military and political comment has to be heard to be believed. The people of vietnam also tell their stories and appear far more humane and informed than their aggressors (except when fighting for the latter). It’s difficult to view this outstanding film without drawing parallels between vietnam and iraq. Note: the documentary contains some harrowing scenes of death and mutilation but they are in context and very necessary illustrations.
  28. This review is from : Hearts And Minds [DVD]

    I’ve just watched this documentary and it has impressed, appalled and educated me. It’s expertly filmed and edited, the print and transfer are impeccable and it looks like it was made yesterday. The film is a clear and powerful perspective on the true nature of warfare and the true idiocy of us foreign policy during the vietnam war. It allows the participants to tell their own stories and often gives them just enough rope to hang themselves in the process. Some of the military and political comment has to be heard to be believed. The people of vietnam also tell their stories and appear far more humane and informed than their aggressors (except when fighting for the latter). It’s difficult to view this outstanding film without drawing parallels between vietnam and iraq. Note: the documentary contains some harrowing scenes of death and mutilation but they are in context and very necessary illustrations.

Comments are closed.